Gary Cobb This is Hypselodoris tryoni (Garrett, 1873) The genus was changed recently.
Gary Cobb Please try to converse in english so we all can read the message thank you.
João Pedro Silva Although that will prevent the use of automatic translations which will drastically reduce the number of "comic reliefs" we need on our daily lives.
Carola Hofmann Hi guys, do you have any idea which nudibranch this is? Found at Cook Island Marine Park, +/- 12 metres deep, 5cm. Maybe Risbecia tryoni?
Chris Spence Gills on a Pair of loving Risbecia Tryoni (those Nudi Experts can correct me if I am wrong!) D300s VR105 +2 Dioptre Nauticam Twin z240 TTL f16, 1/200s. Liberty Wreck Tulamben.
Fadhel AshkaRisbecia tryoni nudibranchs [No Post Processing]
Marine life fans would opt for seeing dolphins, sharks, turtles, and the big fishes, but these extremely colorful species that go by the name, nudibranches, fail to be in any fan's list. These creatures are so slow in the water, you can leave them and seek your buddies and bring them back to the nudibranches location without worrying about these creatures going anywhere. The front antenna are believed to work as taste buds and the back ones are gulls, just like the fish gulls. Believe it or not, some of these nudibraches are intoxicating.
Camera model : Canon EOS 7D
Strobe : INON Z240
F-stop : 16
Exposure time : 1/100sec
ISO setting : 250
Focal length : 60mm
Malida Alcazar But let there be spaces in your togetherness and let the winds of the heavens dance between you. Love one another but make not a bond of love: let it rather be a moving sea between the shores of your souls.
Khalil Gibran
Anilao, Philippines
Sonja Ooms A well fed tryon's risbecia.
Puerto Galera, Philippines
João Pedro Silva Hypselodoris tryoni. Risbecia tryoni is no longer a valid name:
http://www.marinespecies.org/aphia.php?p=taxdetails&id=558642
Sonja Ooms Yeah well as if it isn't complicated enough as it is. Makes it only more difficult for amateurs like me to identify an object. The identification for me as photographer is important in the sense that I can do some limited research on the object to get to know it better and to find it more easily. It also helps other photographers to find it and add it to their photo collection. But thanks anyway for remark, I will keep it in mind. Maybe you can give me a tip where to find a kind of list where they mention changes of names. I am specifically interested in nudibrancs.
Lisa Kelly Great shot!
João Pedro Silva With the Sea Slug Forum closed and lack of regular updates on Nudi Pixel, the best way to keep updated is through WoRMS (world register of marine species). There are also some groups on Facebook like Nudibase - sharing Nudibranch knowledge, but it depends a bit on which part of the world you're interested in.
Scubashooters Dot Net Welcome Sonja!!!! :)
João Pedro Silva My advice is to use whichever tools (guides, websites) you're used to for identification and then check for the validity of the names on WoRMS. There's an important aspect of correct identification which is often underestimated, especially important in good photos such as this one: other photographers and even amateur naturalists may find these photos on web searches as examples of the species and that may propagate on the web reinforcing the misconception. There are some more "scientifically oriented" nudibranch groups on Facebook but are also focused on some geographic region so it depends a lot on where you usually dive. For instance, the most active group is dedicated to NE Atlantic species (extending into the Mediterranean).
João Pedro Silva Medslugs may not be exhaustive for every region (it's not as the name suggests limited to the Mediterranean) but has many species and the nomenclature is updated: http://www.medslugs.de/
Chanon Ngernthongdee ID please...
size 10 cm
Depth around 10m.
Nauticam 7D
Macro 100
Dual Sea&Sea ys-d1 may be left strobe just hang T_T
ISO 100 1/160 f32
Kohsak - Pattaya, Thailand
Mike Bartick Okay, ill Play, here's an easy one to start
Gary Cobb Resbecia tryoni this species like to trail each other! Nice photo.
Ashley Missen Agree with Gary. Where did you find this guy as I have only seen them at Byron bay. Can you send the pic and sighting data to data@nudibase.com so I can add to the database cheers ash
Ashley Missen Hey Gary isn't that spelt Risbecia tyroni
Gary Cobb Nice try...Risbecia tryoni (Garrett, 1873)
Carole Patterson Hi Ashley,
Can you please take me off this list?
Cant keep up with what I get now. :)
Thanks,
Carole
Mike Bartick shot it in the PI, does that count?
Ashley Missen PI ?? Nudibase is global would love more from overseas
James Padfield I have a couple of pictures of Resbecia tryoni (not as good as this one mind!) from Vietnam a few weeks ago. What is this nudibase of which you speak?
Ashley Missen A website that tracks and Ids Nudibranchs www.nudibase.com you can send data into data@nudibase.com cheers Ash
Blogie Robillo Wait... I thought this had already been reclassified as Hypselodoris tryoni?
Ashley Missen Yes It has Blogie this is just an old post that's all that has be commented on recently
Carola Hofmann Hi guys, do you have any idea which nudibranch this is? Found at Cook Island Marine Park, +/- 12 metres deep, 5cm. Maybe Risbecia tryoni?
Penn Dls I think that's it, Kathrin Hachenberg. thanks.
Blogie Robillo Yeah, I do believe this one's Chromodoris leopardus. Risbecia tryoni has solid black spots, while C. leopardus has rings. Very cute individual, this one! :)
Gary Cobb Correct Blogie
Blogie Robillo Thanks, Gary. I learn from the best ;)
Giorgetta Massimo Max Nudibranch Chromodoris Leopardus
Ron Silver Appears to be Risbecia tryoni. See attached for C. leopardus: http://www.nudibranch.org/Sulawesi%20Sea%20Slugs/html/nudibranchs/chromodoris-leopardus.html
Giorgetta Massimo Max Ron Silver comunicated recently:This is Hypselodoris tryoni (Garrett, 1873) The genus was changed recently.
Marcello Di Francesco Happy Valentine's day!!!
Ambon, Indonesia
Canon Eos 500d + Nimar housing
Canon 60 mm macro
2 inon z240
f14 1/240 iso 100
Isabella Maffei lovely
Lea Meng nice!! new nudi will born in next couple of mths...
Carolyn Thomson Very cute
Mark Farrer Great shot
Fabio Russo None little new nudi from different species, on the left we have Chromodoris coi, on the right Risbecia tryoni... when the Nudibranch are mating they used to leave the right side of the body to the partner, so we can find the calssic position of mating Head-tail, head-tail, here we have head-head....i'm Sorry happy Valentine days ;)
Marcello Di Francesco Fabio i know that are different species, but this immage is so lovely that i like use for this day !! ;-)
Fabio Russo i pubblish an article abaut slugs love:
http://www.aiam.info/index.php/articoli/53-monografie-ed-osservazioni/2626-speciale-di-san-valentino-qil-nudibranco-innamoratoq
Sorry only in Italian :)
Marcello Di Francesco thanks fabio .. very useful article !! :-)))
Ken Thongpila Oh! Are they cute! Lovely shot Marcello :-)
Edoardo Spacca SS Liberty, Tulamben, Bali
Sea&Sea DX2G, 2xInon z240, FIT diopter 5x
1/500, F5.2, ISO100
and for the name, i'm very bad and dont have a taxonomy of nudis, so if anyone wants to chip in i'd be delighted... :-)
Massimo Coreachromodoris kuniei
Edoardo Spacca grazie!!!!
Roy Arthur David Lontoh I would say both are Risbecia tryoni ;)
Edoardo Spacca well, funny enough it seems there is little ambiguity as on some pics on the web it is also classified as chromodoris leopard.....
Orietta RivoltaChromodoris leopardus has the black spots are quite large and several of them are hollow. By contrast, Risbecia tryoni would have more numerous smaller black spots with no white centres.
Ken Thongpila I would say Risbecia tryoni as well... I saw them in Tulamben too. Nice shot with 2 together :-)
Ashley Missen They are Risbecia tryoni - Chromodoris leopardus has dark circles not spots - nice double front shot - Cheers Ash
Gary Cobb HEY EVERYONE! When posting photos of Nudibranchs with names always use the whole name i.e.. Risbecia tryoni not R. tryoni. You only use the abbreviated name after you have used the whole name in any particular list or article.
Stefan Follows Nudibranch - Risbecia tryoni
Canon G10, Canon WP-DC28, 1xInon D2000 f5.6 1/250 ISO100
Hin Yippon, Ang Thong Marine Park, Gulf of Thailand
Michael Lawrence Yet another fine example of a Canon G series image. I need to see how these print.
Stefan Follows very well Michael on proper photo print paper up to about A2 size (no crop). been selling framed pics since i had my G10 so i'm a very happy puppy.
Ashley Missen This is a Risbecia tyroni as Chromodoris leopardus has small rings not dots - Great shot -Cheers Ash
Patrik GoodRisbecia tryoni not tyroni (if it's not C. leopardus which is a hard call in the first place)
Mactan Cebu Scuba Thanks, guys.
Ashley Missen And thank you Patrik for the spell check
Gary Cobb Sorry guys you both are wrong! This is Hypselodoris tryoni (Garrett, 1873) according to the new research done. And to the person who thought this was Chromodoris leopardus Rudman, 1987, the author does not have (brackets)! The genus was never changed!
Gary Cobb C. leopardus has rings and H. Tryoni has solid spots.
Ashley Missen Has that paper been published yet as I didn't think it was a finish document yet - too many inconsistencies
Blogie Robillo I'm confused... Has Risbecia tryoni been renamed to Hypselodoris tryoni, or is H. tryoni an altogether different species?
Ashley Missen Same species, there is a paper out that is talking about resorting and grouping the Chromodoridae family
Blogie Robillo Oh right. I did download that document. However, since you and Gary were saying that it wasn't final yet, I didn't finish reading it...
Gary Cobb Richard Willan has said we have to abide by these latest finding. The technique is new and very conclusive. Bill Rudman said for a long time this would happen and it has. Yes some of it is incomplete but most of it proven by DNA not the traditional "comparing" of morphology and internal parts. I have made 62 changes to the New nudibranch ID Australia/NewZealand App and will upload the update this week. Its a pain in the ass but... (the paper has been accepted by the scientific community including Richard Willan.
Nerida Wilson Hi, just like to add that just because a paper is published does NOT mean that its accepted by the wider scientific community. It has been accepted by one or more reviewers (in PLOS one journal). I think that many of the groups presented by Johnson & Gosliner are correct, and a better reflection of the evolution of the group, but the tree is not particularly well-supported. So there is definitely a need for more data. And more discussion. That's how science should work.... cheers
Blogie Robillo In view of all this, which online resource do you think can be the most trusted in terms of nudibranch nomenclature?
Nerida Wilson To be honest, its a bit of a mess right now. Sites like the World Register of Marine Species have only made part of the changes suggested by this recent paper. Not sure if they don't like some of the results, or they just haven't finished yet.... Everyone needs to be patient, and remember...a rose by any other name!
Mactan Cebu Scuba I just love to take pictures. ;)
Blogie Robillo Are these Chromodoris kuniei? Spotted this pair at about 50ft at San Juan Reef, off the western coast of Samal Is., Davao, Philippines; 29 Jan 2012.
Alicia Mirabilis Surely not chromodoris kuniei... maybe risbecia tryoni
Alicia Mirabilis btw kuniei is the one in my profile pic ;)
Gary Cobb No these are Risbecia tryoni Garrett, 1873
Arantxa Di Mare And...could not be Risbecia tryoni ??? :)
Ashley Missen OK let see http://www.nudipixel.net/species/risbecia_tryoni/ vs http://www.nudipixel.net/species/chromodoris_kuniei/ the only other on apart from Risbecia tryoni it could be is is Chromodoris lepordus but they have rings not dots - definately Risbecia tyroni
Arantxa Di Mare Sorry..I haven't read Ashely's note and I have written incorretly my note....I agree with Ashley and I think that it could be Risbecia tryoni
Gary Cobb This is Resbecia tryoni
Matthias Wildermuth Hi Gary could u have a look at that brown nudi i posted in nudibase please. Thanks
Gary Cobb Repost it OK?
Matthias Wildermuth Can do it here then thanks
Gary Cobb I just sent you an email from Richard!
Gary Cobb Same critter!
Matthias Wildermuth Got the email. Found it on the other side of the bay at 2 spots maybe 100 m appart. One spot had the same kind of eggs. Never seen before yet. Not sure what R means with investigtion? Thanks u need it?
Gary Cobb Nice find! Very cryptic.
Matthias Wildermuth Extremly well adapted to sponge love it ;-)